3.5 stars - It wasn't as good as the first one and even not as good as the second but its madeline writing which i love and thats a lot . I found Ellie and dirty story more intriguing from the main plot and think that they should probably get their own book . Didn't feel that cage character was well established , sometimes he acted stupid and immature others he was smart and strong , its like he was developing with the story but somewhere along the line he's been lost .